Melo, we're ready when you are... (Nuggets/Suns recap)
Hanging out at the Blue Sky lounge post-game at Pepsi Center tonight, I was watching ESPN's "NBA Fastbreak" which flashed the following type on the screen: "Utah Jazz: The hottest team in the NBA?" Until five or so hours ago, you could have said that about the Nuggets.
The Nuggets streak of playing solid basketball (excluding the debacle in Oklahoma City last Friday) came to a screeching halt tonight and it's clear that the Nuggets can't sustain that high level of play without Carmelo Anthony getting back on the floor.
What I'm about to say is going to piss off half the readers of this site, but in my opinion, there's something fishy about Anthony's injured ankle. Melo missed his sixth consecutive game tonight, but for the third consecutive game Nuggets head coach George Karl predicted that Melo would play, only to be proven wrong. Why would the head coach predict that a player will play three times in a row if he didn't believe that the player could play?
I don't want to start rumors of Melo faking it. I'm not in that locker room. I'm not talking to Nuggets trainer Jim Gillen every day. It's not my body. But I am questioning Melo's toughness because a) he didn't have a severely sprained ankle, and b) it doesn't take two weeks to recover from a non-severe sprained ankle. The much older and more weathered Chauncey Billups also has a sprained ankle, and he doesn't seem to have a problem playing each night (although he was a step slow tonight).
The general consensus among the denizens of Pepsi Center that I talked to tonight was that Melo looks fine and should be playing. Again, we're just fans. What do we know, right? But if you study Melo's body language, the way he walks to and from the locker room, observe how he interacts with his teammates doing battle out there and read between the lines with Karl's latest statements on the issue, the fans have every right to question this situation.
I have a sneaky suspicion Melo will be on the Staples Center floor on Friday against the Lakers. And it's about time, too, because this blowout home loss to the Suns - the Nuggets worst home defeat in ages - proved that the Nuggets can't keep winning games sans Melo, as they've done admirably this season. Billups and Kenyon Martin, having shouldered the load for the Nuggets for weeks now, both looked worn down and played their worst games in recent memory. And when the Nuggets players collectively decided not to play defense against Phoenix, they didn't have the offensive firepower provided by Melo to play shootout basketball with the Suns. They were in a lose-lose situation from the opening tip.
So Melo, if you're reading this, we need you out there. We're ready when you are.
The view from the not-so-cheap-seats...
...first off, many thanks to Denver Stiffs reader Paul M. for inviting me to the game tonight! I owe you one!
...the game opened with a Mariachi band rendition of the "Star Spangled Banner." Paul turned to me and said; "What is this? A Spurs game?" And then the PA announcer introduced the Nuggets players in Spanish.
...the Nuggets had great passing and ball movement early, and then abandoned it by the second quarter for too much one-on-three play. It was ugly.
...Rocky made yet another behind-the-back, half court shot. Now that Rocky's accuracy is off the charts, perhaps the Nuggets should add this shot to their playbook?
...J.R. Smith had good patience throughout the game, and seems to have settled back into a good space mentally.
...I sat on the side of the stadium where J.R. does his shtick when introduced, and he has a great camaraderie with the fans. We've all seen this on TV or from other vantage points inside Pepsi Center, but you don't really appreciate it until you sit nearby.
...K-Mart had blue pads on his knees in the first half and then switched to white pads on his calves in the second half. Just curious what this is about.
...the funniest moment in an otherwise very unfunny night was watching Nuggets assistant coach John Welch bark orders at J.R. during a Nuggets free throw. J.R. was standing near half court and well within earshot, and no matter how many times Welch barked at him, J.R. never flinched, never looked in Welch's direction and never acknowledged that he heard a word Welch said. Welch probably should have saved his breath.
...the Suns seven-seconds-or-less offense worked tonight, as they chucked long-range jump shots soon after passing half court and made a high percentage of them, catching the Nuggets defense completely off guard.
...curiously, Steve Nash and Amar'e Stoudemire were re-inserted around the five-minute of the fourth quarter, even though Phoenix had the game well in hand.
Non-Stiff of the Night
-Jason Richardson: Nash and Stoudemire had good nights, too, but it seemed like Richardson had a slew of baskets in the third quarter that broke the game open for Phoenix. Even with a Nuggets defender in his face, Richardson's shots were going down from everywhere.
Stiff of the Night
-The Nuggets Energy: I'm not going to call out individual players here. The Nuggets went through the motions tonight, never took control of the energy of the game and essentially cheated the fans out of the hard-earned money we spend on tickets. We don't expect the Nuggets to win every night at Pepsi Center, but we do expect an earnest effort...especially on two days rest between home games. It's too bad they don't offer refunds.
Opposition's Take: Bright Side of the Sun
Photo courtesy of AP Photos: David Zalubowski
0 recs |
116 comments
|
Comments
Well
I don’t know if u watch a lot of the Suns but the Suns blow double digit leads in a span of two minutes. It has happened before and Alvin Gentry didn’t want to risk a meltdown. It wasn’t to disrespect the Nuggets it was just to make sure the Suns don’t blow this game. Anyway beat LA
Steve Nash plays D!!
horrible loss...
should have fought back…
"Do not rest in defense. You can spend 24 seconds in offense on resting. If you do good enough on defense, you will be able to rest on offense."
Personally
I would prefer Melo take his time recovering rather than rush back and re-injure it. He did sprain it pretty badly, and Melo’s injury was much much worse than what happened to Chauncey’s ankle. It’s mid season, the Nuggets are in a good spot in the standings, so if Melo is not ready to come back 100% there’s absolutely no reason to put him in a position where he can’t be on top of his game and is threatening his health for the future.
by snafu on Feb 4, 2010 2:18 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
Point taken
But in that case, he better sit out the All Star Game. We’re going to start dropping crucial games against division and conference rivals without him.
by Artimus Mangilord on Feb 4, 2010 12:28 PM MST up reply actions
Melo dramatic
Well Marc Spears from Yahoo just said Melo barring a miracle heal will miss next 2 games and return next tuesday against Dallas. Add this to the long list of Melo speculation but one thing I have learned is not to get optimistic about Nugs returning from injury this year. Got this from Spears twitter
There are 4 games before the break all against top teams so it would be nice to see Melo back soon. Then again Melo is in the all star game. This game exposed why Melo should never have gotten hurt. When we were getting stops the Nuggets went cold and whenever they hit a big shot to stop our run we quit playing D. If the Nugs put the Hornets away when they should that game never goes into OT where Melo went down. No 20 point scorer in this game equals no win. But the Nugs are now 5-11 when they don;t score 100 points and they must be able to win more with defense, Melo or no Melo. The only reason I feel we are not competing with the Lakers record is because the Nugs are often playing exceptional defense or exceptional offense but they rarely play solid on both ends of the floor consistently. At home we are usually able to get big scoring runs when we need them and that didn’t happen tonight.
All I can say is the Nuggets must try to avoid another lull following the recent hot streak of wins. The next 5 games are pivotal. I’ll take 3 wins any way we can get them. Too optimistic?
Good things about this game
Afflalo was extremely aggressive, led the team with 8 free throw attempts on 7 shots and had 2 blocks and 2 steals. Graham had 13 and 7 in 21 minutes but shot too much. Lawson made all all of his 3 shots and 3 free throws but only played 20 minutes. JR went to the rim quite a bit and notched 5 assists. The supporting cast is raising their level of play while Melo sits out
for gods sake Andrew
you need to go watch the altitude rebroadcast…Melo was being interviewed by Hastings and Marlowe for a good 20 minutes…
lets not go down this road again eh?
"Groovy" Ash from Evil Dead 2
"No one came from miles around / and said man your music is really hot" No One Came...Deep Purple
no melo is not the issue
grant hill lost close to 5 years off of his career from playing on a sprained ankle. orlando lost a ton of money paying a max contract for a player that hardly played. melo also lost time this season because of a knee injury. the loss is due to denver’s 2 bad habits. getting off to a bad start and allowing the opponent back into the game. this happens for one reason. nuggets failed to execute in the half court offense. steve nash is a great player but is very limited on the defensive end. denver failed to force the issue in the paint on offense. there is nothing wrong with playing hard and physical without being dirty or flagrant. nuggets on too many occasions will not post up the opponents guards. teams like golden state, nawlins, clippers and the rockets have some small guards that denver can exploit. shot clock management, setting solid picks and making the extra pass force opponents to use energy on defense and has a negitive effect on the offensive end. nuggets can make thing easy on themselves by playing smarter.
pick up a calf every day pretty soon you will be picking up a cow
Wow Andrew
Im so dissapointed with this loss. And yes, I actually consider THIS an “unacceptable” loss. To me it’s worse than losing to the bucks, but you’ve reached an all-time low my man. As I was reading your recap I checked the name at the top and realized “yeah, I didn’t think this was bill simmons…”
you’re kidding right? First you take credit for JR’s “re-awakening” and now youre uncovering the Melo conspiracy. It’s truly tiresome. What part of Carmelo Anthony leads you to believe that he doesn’t want to be out there. On National TV. first against the Spurs, and now against the Suns.
You’re actually basing this theory on how he is WALKING to and from the locker room?
The injury that was stated was a high ankle sprain. Generally a three week FULL RECOVERY.
I’m with you on the fact that I want him out there. Seriously I am. But to suggest that he’s purposefully sitting games out so he can what, “show the world that this team needs him?” is ludacris. During the game while talking to a friend I said, “this must be bad if after three promises to play, he hasn’t. But I guess that the trainers and coach Karl probably meant ‘game-time decision’ and as frustrating as it is, them’s the breaks…”
quick recap: he doesn’t sit on the bench when he’s hurt earlier this season for a couple of games; and now he’s able to play but instead decides that chasing a title and scoring champ honors aren’t as important as….what? What is he sitting out for? That’s the part I wanna hear you say. Tell us. Melo is sitting out because….
I’m as frustrated as the next guy about losing last night as I am probably the BIGGEST Suns hater but I gotta be honest man, I’m a little worried about you as a fan. I think your “job” as the guy who has the “most read nuggets BLOG” has gone to your head.
Maybe the players do hop on this site and read what we’re talking about, but listen to what you’re saying! You can say what you think, of course, but are you saying that Melo is sitting out because he wants to be traded? Seriously, what’s behind your conspiracy?
You’ve said before that you play/played the game…have you had a high ankle sprain? Have you ever had an injury that didn’t reveal itself in everyday walking around kind of stuff but when you had to actually push yourself physically that’s when it showed that you weren’t 100%?
here’s a little nugget for my fellow nugget fans brethren: my wife’s sister dated Booby Miles (Friday night lights) in high school and when he got hurt she said there was “nothing different about him physically when we went to Prom. no limping, nothing. Everything seemed normal, he just couldnt play football.”
I’m guessing that Melo knows what he can do and what he can’t. And at the end of the day, he’s the only person who does.
But hey, let’s add him to the list of Nuggets that we’re willing as fans to trade (JR, NENE, KENYON) because, godamnit, he’s not doing exactly what we want him to.
What will you find wrong with this team when we win a championship?
I now know what adults said to me when I was growing up and said/did something without all the facts: “Shame on you”.
Shame on you, Andrew.
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 4, 2010 3:45 AM MST via mobile reply actions 2 recs
+1
A huge part of Melo’s game is that quick jab step and the driving to the basket, both of which requires the ankle to be 100% for full effectiveness. .if he doesn’t feel that he can do those moves then he turns into a jump shooter. Then the game recap is full about why Melo didn’t shoot and FT’s because he wasn’t aggressive. Can’t have it both ways.
by NuggetsLife on Feb 4, 2010 4:33 AM MST up reply actions 1 recs
easy, sternfluffskobe...
i know youre the rose colored glasses, eternal optimist, glass half full, never is heard a discouraging word, uncondional blind love kind of nuggs fan. i generally like your optimistic posts. however…
you’re WAY too quick to question someone elses fanhood when they even slightly doubt any aspect of this team. it comes off real holier than thou and its getting tired quick.
seriously sfk, i generally like your cheeriness. but you get real judgemental, real quick when someone doesn’t see this team exactly as you do.
by calvin brodus on Feb 4, 2010 6:28 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
at least he is on the bench this time right? not recieveing treatment.
While i dont agree with SFK’s attack on andrews fanhood, nor would i ever, I do like the question he raises as to why melo would sit out. It has be thought before that he sat out games because they werent nationally televised, but the spurs and suns were. I just cant see any reason for melo not playing other than his ankle just isnt fully ready. How many times has someone come back too quickly from injury and just not been able to play at their usual level, or injure themselves worse. And even if he isnt injured worse, if he is aggravating it every game, when is it supposed to fully finish healing? I want melo to play, I know we need melo to play. I think melo knows that. Lets just give melo our support. Or we could trade him for a fully healthy Darko…. lmao.. Lets go Nuggs
+1
What’s ironic to me is that SFK is doing to Andrew what we are taking umbrage (sp?) with him doing to Melo: questioning a well-respected leader’s loyalty. Clearly Andrew is a loyal Nuggets fan. Melo is clearly a loyal Nugget with one goal – a championship. I think until proven otherwise, both statements remain true.
What bothers me is that it is an ever-growing alter that Andrew preaches from and he ought to remember that “with great power, comes great responsibility.”
Practice doesn't make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect.
Is Big Mickey D the second Stiffs account for SFK?
LOL, you guys always agree on everything it seems.
by Gasus on Feb 5, 2010 9:58 AM MST up reply actions 1 recs
That's hilarious!
No but Big Mickey D seems like an incredibly smart guy/girl. : )
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 5, 2010 11:27 AM MST via mobile up reply actions 1 recs
+1
Practice doesn't make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect.
by Big Mickey D on Feb 5, 2010 12:17 PM MST up reply actions
The things you say...
[I don’t want to start rumors of Melo faking it] – You just did.
You know, like here: […there’s something fishy about Anthony’s injured ankle.]
And here: […a) he didn’t have a severely sprained ankle, and b) it doesn’t take two weeks to recover from a sprained ankle.]
You’re speculating. Not reporting. Not performing research.
“The importance of proper rehabilitation after an ankle sprain cannot be overemphasized, especially when the debilitating consequences of decreased range of motion, persistent pain and swelling, and chronic joint instability are considered. After initial acute treatment, a rehabilitation regimen is pivotal in speeding return to activity and preventing chronic instability. In a recent military series19 it was found that lack of rehabilitation of ankle sprains delayed return to duty for several months.”
you can read more here: http://www.aafp.org/afp/2001/0101/p93.html
by theflusher on Feb 4, 2010 3:51 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
Thanks, Rex Morgan
1. This is a blog, not the AP wire
2. As hard as they may try to report the facts, bloggers are not given press credentials
3. Following #3, the entire Nuggets organization has obfuscated the issue and they have a track record of doing so (e.g., JR Smith likely to be traded…nevermind, he’s not going to be traded)
They’ve waffled on Melo since the Hornets game. Cut Andrew some slack.
by Artimus Mangilord on Feb 4, 2010 12:42 PM MST up reply actions 1 recs
Trying to read between the lines....
Since I’ve been here, if I would ever trust anybody with injuries, it’s Melo," Karl said. “I think the injury, when we saw it on film, everyone said it was bad. But Melo kind of gave us this feel that he’ll be back. So we trusted Melo, but I think the injury is a little higher up, which is more dangerous and more soreness. And we just have to live with it.”
hmmmmm…….
Maybe you can help me out.
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 4, 2010 4:08 AM MST via mobile reply actions 1 recs
On Nates Fanpost (ironically that no one has commented on)
Anthony was selected by fans to start for the Western Conference during the Feb. 14 NBA All-Star Game in Dallas, but he said he will not participate if he can’t play in at least one of the next four games leading into the break.
"I wouldn’t do that. I couldn’t have people talking bad about me like that," Anthony said. "I care about the All-Star game, but I really care about my team."
again, hmmmmmm………
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 4, 2010 7:38 PM MST via mobile up reply actions 1 recs
Rec'd
Be careful! Quoting sources like NBA players and coaches might actually lead us to – uh oh – THE TRUTH…
Practice doesn't make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect.
melo must not be ready, i mean it was a game on espn right, NATIONAL TV
melo always steps up his game on national tv, so im sure he would have loved to play, just let him come back 100% we dont want melo going in for some ankle surgery now do we?
i cant beleive you would think hes faking it....
it clearly looked bad when he landed on it… he also has been known to play through injuries…. last year he had elbow problems all year, played through a game w a broken hand… hes a warrior, it must be serious if he isnt playing
Sprains
As a kid and on into my 20s my ankles were perma-sprained from skateboarding and basketball. I can’t think of one day in that era of my life where each and every morning I would almost collapse getting out of bed. It wasn’t until I loosened up that I could get around and not really feel the effects of perpetual spraining. Of course I didn’t compete at the level Melo is. So I would say, these things take a little time if you want them to heal correctly and be ready for the long haul. Otherwise you’re in “perma-sprain” territory.
He's not saying Melo's faking it
He’s claiming that Melo won’t tough it out or play through pain because he wants to protect his scoring title or all star appearance or something. It doesn’t make any sense to me either.
The decision whether or not he plays goes way beyond just him.
This is...
irresponsible journalism. You can’t have it both ways, if you want to be taken seriously and get press credentials then you have to do serious work and be a responsible correspondent. Posting something on a media outlet, which is supposed to be the number 1 read Nuggets site, that is based purely off of speculation and conjecture is just poor. You are certainly entitled to your opinion but you can’t call out a player, “If your reading this Melo”, for an opinion that has no factual evidence to support it.
Melo has never given any reason to believe that he would not play hurt. It sounds to me like he wants to play, it sounds to me when I read between the lines that he’s telling Karl that he can play and someone else, someone you know like the trainers perhaps, is telling Karl he can’t play. I said in the thread that even if Karl knows he’s not going to play its still advantageous to us if we act like there’s a chance he might play because it means the other team has to prepare for that. If Melo could go, he would go. I’m sure of tat. I’ll take his istory of being a tough player who wants to play over your surmising from your single viewpoint in the stands
wow
Ok i haven’t commented for a long time, because basically i just enjoy reading what everyone writes and agree with them… plus i’m way too tired from work and baby.
But, i have to tell you andrew the only fishy thing about Melo is that the injury is probably worse than they have told us. he might have torn ligament, and i’m pretty sure the only solution for that is time. And as someone else said earlier if you have plaid B-ball or any sport before (and you have) you would know that there is sometimes injuries that you can walk around fine but when it comes to making a sport move, you just can’t do it. Maybe we learned from having CB come back too early and get re-injured.
This is second time you are trying to start a rumor ( I know you are saying you aren’t). You were questioning why he wouldn’t sit on the side line after his injury the first part of this year.
come on MANG
My rebuttal...
My rebuttal…
Fellow Stiffs,
I knew calling out Melo’s toughness would start a fire storm here, so allow me a quick rebuttal and take this for what it’s worth.
- I’m not a journalist, I’m a fan advocate. My job here at DS is to comment on the news, not break it. And until that changes, readers need to understand that what’s written here is opinion and not news.
- Even though I’m not obligated to do so, I still adhere strictly to the rules of journalism – i.e. I don’t say something is a fact unless I absolutely know so or see it with my own two eyes. Note that I was clear that I didn’t want to start a rumor and explicitly wrote that I’m not in the locker room to be making fact-base judgment calls on the condition of a player’s health.
- Am I questioning Melo’s toughness as a fan? From the fan’s perspective, you bet. Last I checked, fans are allowed to question the toughness of the players whose salaries we pay for. Am I suggesting he’s purposely faking it? No. I’m saying that the situation is fishy, that’s all.
- Melo is the best player on team (maybe not the most valuable, but certainly "the best") and we’d be nowhere without him. That said, he can be a bit of a diva and always has been. Any true Nuggets fan knows that. This doesn’t mean I don’t love him as a player, I just call it like I see it. Again, in my opinion.
I don’t expect anyone to agree with my opinion on Melo’s injury. But please keep this rebuttal in mind when you reply to this game recap.
At the end of the day, I love a good debate and love being proven wrong. Especially by my fellow Stiffs. Remember, this is a family fight and we all want the same thing: for the Nuggets to win! And we need Melo back sooner than later if that’s going to happen…
Andrew Feinstein | DenverStiffs.com | denverstiffs@gmail.com
by Andrew Feinstein on Feb 4, 2010 7:20 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
I was disappointed in the game...
…but not nearly as disappointed as I was by this “recap” and lame-ass rebuttal. First off, the recap contained almost nothing of interest concerning the game. You’d be better of putting it in the fanpost section along with all the other op-ed articles that speculate on trades, injuries, all-star appearances, and Baron Davis’ beard.
Come’on Andrew, really. What’s the ultimate goal for the Nuggets this year? To get 60 wins? To not lose a game on home court? To “show off” on national television? Sure, those are all fine and noble pursuits, but that’s not what these guys get paid for.
Melo’s ultimate goal, as he has said time and time again, is to win the championship. How does that factor into any decision to play? First off, his team is 8 and 4 without him. That means they’re winning 75% of the games. That’s better than their season record. They’re doing well enough without him that he should take time to heal. Sure, any loss feels bad, but a win in February is worth what? Is it worth Melo reinjuring or aggravating his ankle leading to another 6 game absence?
It’s a long season (for the players, that is, I personally could watch a game every night), and while early games are important, it’s the end-haul that gets the trophy. Honestly, which would you prefer; that the Nuggets not lose another regular season game but not win the championship, or squeak in as an 8th seed and go all the way? I know, I know, it’d be better if they had home-court advantage – but at what cost?
Is home-court advantage worth more than a healthy Melo, Billups, KMart, or Nene? Not in my book.
Rather than just call-out players from your comfy chair with unsupported and frivilous claims, if we really believe that they read our posts, why don’t we be more productive and offer some advice that may actually be of use?
by NuggBuckets on Feb 4, 2010 8:42 AM MST up reply actions 1 recs
Actually, I was wrong.
“Come’on Andrew, really. What’s the ultimate goal for the Nuggets this year? To get 60 wins? To not lose a game on home court? To "show off" on national television? Sure, those are all fine and noble pursuits, but that’s not what these guys get paid for. "
To “show off” on national television is EXACTLY what these guys get paid for.
I still would rather a couple of losses in the middle of the year and a healthy Melo for the playoffs though.
Recap
Nate does quite a bit of fact based analysis and stat stuffs in the recap. This game there wasn’t a whole lot to say though. The Suns pretty much had their way with the Nugs and owned them at everything
by runningdonut on Feb 4, 2010 10:48 AM MST up reply actions
+1
Andrew,
Say what you want. I’ve never had a bad sprain (knock on wood) so I don’t know how long you should be out. But even if Melo should be out, there is nothing wrong with questioning why he isn’t back yet, especially with the (shitty) coach continually saying that he is ready to play.
Thanks for all the hard work.
That's the funniest thing I've ever heard
Somehow you’ve found a way to blame Karl for this…you’re good.
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 4, 2010 10:51 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
It's not so hard
to blame Karl for things – he provides lots of ammunition. If I see the three guard lineup, birdman guarding a point guard or Lawson guarding a center again I’m going to puke.
-1
Boo. You can’t have it both ways. You can’t get downright indignant about not getting credentials or being fed information about Nuggets’ events like the Bowling Bawl and then hide behind the “I’m not a journalist, I’m a fan advocate” bullshit. Boo.
Practice doesn't make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect.
+1
I have the same feelings on this topic as you Andrew. Good for you to stand up for yourself and say what you are thinking even though you know the warewolves will be coming to get you. Anything negative said about Melo on this blog cause severe hate directed towards the person that wrote it. Keep standing up for yourself as others may start to see that Melo has a lot of things he needs to work on if we are going to consider him in conversations discussing the greats of all time.
time will tell
when the injury first happened melo insisted it was nothing major. this is not a case where it was misstated once or twice melo would be ready to play. every game since the injury it was reported he would play the next game. there are 3 possibilities. first nuggets have a genuine medical mystery on their hands that they have not been able to solve. second nuggets are aware that the injury is worse than what they are stating in public. third melo for his own reasons is taking his time coming back. i am willing to give melo the benefit of the doubt for now. he continues to miss games up to the all star game then has a miraculous medical recovery in time for the league showcase andrew will be vindicated.
pick up a calf every day pretty soon you will be picking up a cow
You could say the same if he just shows up for the game before the All-Star game
Like he is saying now. If he doesn’t play in at least one game he is gonna sit out the All-Star game. Sounds like a plan if you are trying to keep your league lead in scoring by getting DNPs. Dude is gonna lose the scoring title if he wants his team to win and he knows it. Maybe he just figures the longer he holds it the better chance he has at league MVP…
My Theory on Melo
I agree with Andrew that something is not quite right about Melo missing the last couple of games. My assumption is that if this were the playoffs, he would have played, admittedly not at 100%. By the way, most players right now are not playing at 100%. My guess is Karl and the FO want Melo to play, but Melo wants to be 100% to preserve his chances at winning the scoring title and the All Star MVP. We all know both of these things are important to him. I don’t resent Melo for this, it is just who he is. But , we no doubt need him at 100% heading to the playoffs if we want any shot at the Finals. I think this points to the need for another Big that can ably fill in for Melo Kmart or Nene when they miss a few games. Time to swing Big Bertha Stan….
by ACEIII on Feb 4, 2010 6:00 PM MST via mobile up reply actions
I cannot tell if this is a serious post or not
I hope there is some kind of tongue-in-cheek thing going on here or some level of humor I don’t get.
Oherwise, its just a cheap shot at Melo for really no good reason.
Since you have already taken credit for JR’s’ turnaround, is this some attempt to motivate Melo?
Melo not tough??!! Really. That’s false. As others have already stated he’s played through elbow and knee injuries all last season. I don’t believe for one minute that Melo doesn’t have the heart or guts or whatever to be out there.
If he can’t cut or jump, he’s ineffective.
I think you owe Melo an apology
2009 Colorado Rockies - Greatest comeback in MLB history to win NL WildCard
Brad Hawpe - Will prove the doubters wrong
Troy Tulowitzki - Best SS in the MLB - 2010 MVP
"With a guy like Melo, it’s tough to stop him with one person. You can’t. I don’t know one guy who can stop Melo on a consistent basis."-CP3
PS Let's win the NL West in 2010, shall we?
Seriously
Melo comes into the season 15 pounds lighter, leads the team in scoring and free throw attempts and bullies his way to being the top scorer in the NBA. There aren’t many players who take more contact than Melo. He was still coming off a knee injury when the ankle went down. Some guys just can’t catch a break
by runningdonut on Feb 4, 2010 11:00 AM MST up reply actions
His appearance on Altitude bugged me
because he said many times that he wasn’t coming back until he was 100 %. Probably just poorly worded, but he left the impression with me that Andrew expressed.
none of us actually know what's going on, so how can we yell at each other?
andrew isn’t a journalist guys. this is a blog. he does a damn good job “tricking us” by having the scoop on what’s going on with the nuggets by doing his research and having good relationships with the right people. but at the end of the day, he’s just a guy writing about the nuggets. so he’s allowed to have his opinion without being called out for bad journalism.
that said, i’m personally disagreeing with andrew on this one. i’ve played sports for years and over the course of those years i’ve sprained each of my ankles. at the time of the sprain, i never thought they were bad injuries and i even played on them right after, because i felt OK. it wasn’t until later that i realized how bad the injury was, and even with physical therapy (i was out for 5 weeks all told and should have been out for more but i refused to not play in my final college games my senior year) my ankles have never really felt the same, and i can’t play on them without taping them/wearing braces. ankle injuries tend to be chronic, and i’m sure melo is just as pissed as we are that he wasn’t out on the floor. i’ve been there, and i’m sure he felt fine, he may even have tried to practice, but i bet planting and pivoting on that foot just didn’t feel right and he had to sit out again.
i don’t think anyone’s lying to us, i don’t think there’s a conspiracy, and i don’t think melo is being a diva. everyone wants melo to play just as badly as melo wants to play. i think he’s just got himself an injury that takes a bit longer to heal than he hopes and i’m sure his worst nightmare is going out before he’s ready and getting himself a season-ending injury. hell, that’s my worst nightmare for this team too.
i think we should just be patient and see what happens.
so andrew: don’t be too harsh on melo just yet, but good job starting a fire! ;)
and my fellow commenting fans: don’t be so hard on andrew. (and you should take this as a compliment, because i don’t know if you’ve read other blogs but they’re nothing like this one. well done to both you and nate)
In defense of Andrew...
I was the stiff that went to the game with Andrew. In Andrew’s defense, when is the last time that you have EVER heard a coach predict that a player would play, only to be proven wrong, 3 games in a row? Personally, I have never seen this happen before. It is apparent that Karl thinks he can play. Andrew may not talk to Jim Gillen, but I bet Karl does. Why can’t Andrew speculate?
Anyways, I am going to miss the Stiffs gathering because I will be in Maui Friday drinking a Mojito watching the Nuggets destroy Luke Walton’s Lakers. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_R6YpLpV90
Have you ever heard a coach blow more hot air than Karl?
Always take what Karl says with a grain of salt. He says some stupid, baffling #### sometimes.
I remember that happening all the time back in 1977-78 . .
The code word was “day to day” injury, meaning if the player was tough, he would suit up. Turned out Walton was pretty badly hurt, never should have tried to suit up and ended up suing the team and the trainer and fleeing for the Clippers.
I also recall one of my favorite players of all time, Terrell Brandon, taking 2 months to come back from an ankle sprain that was supposed to be 2-3 weeks, playing too early and hurting it again.
I think the Nugs should be careful with ‘Melo. Wether Andrew is right about other fishy stuff going on, I couldn’t say.
Coaches say players are going to go when they know they're not all the time
The point is to not tip off the opposition, why is that so hard to understand?
by Zachm219 on Feb 4, 2010 5:19 PM MST up reply actions 2 recs
light that match
I will watch the replay on NBA Broadband tonight, only saw highlights. Sounds like our Nuggs, w/o Melo, just had an off night where nobody managed to light the spark. Chauncy and Kenyon shot poorly and everyone else had average outings. In other words, no one stepped up.
Two things for GK: 1) the coach has a duty to light a match under the buns of a dragging team; 2) Ty Lawson deserves more minutes when he’s hot and others are cold.
Melo ain't fakin
they just want him healthy for the final push. Hate to players the LAkers w/o him, though.
My take, from the GDT:
I don’t understand why Melo keeps saying it wasn’t a very bad sprain at all and will be ready for the next game, then doesn’t play. Every game he missed from this injury, he said he was going to be ready to play for. It’s a little confusing how a "much less serious ankle sprain than ones" Melo has had in the past is keeping him out so much longer than normal.
I saw the game, it certainly didn’t look like it was a minor sprain. Missing more than a week indicates it was a mild sprain at least, if not serious. A serious sprain could mean 3-6 weeks. We’re already going on two weeks now. So what was reported as a minor sprain was actually already at least a mild sprain. I guess making each opponent prepare as though Melo will play, can be advantage. I guess I understand this. I just hope it’s not far more serious than is being let known.
So we know two things for sure: Melo has stated multiple times that “I’ll be ready” shortly before the last 6 games in a row. Melo has not played the last 6 games. So, Melo is saying he’s good to go, but ends up not playing. This leads me to believe that Melo feels as though his ankle is right, but he’s not showing it in drills and evaluations by the trainers. So two possibilities:
1. Melo’s ankle is still bothering him to the point where he isn’t able to produce the same quickness off the dribble as he was earlier in the year. He says he’s ready to go, feels good, but because he hasn’t demonstrated that ability, the trainers hold him out. The Nuggets have a 2 1/2 game lead over the Jazz and are second in the West by two games. Trainers are being extremely cautious.
If this is the case, I do not expect Melo to play again before the All-Star break.
2. Melo’s ankle is NOT bothering him to the point where he’s not making the cuts, but trainers are still being cautious. Melo says he’ll go, goes through some practices and the staff isn’t seeing dropstep spins at 1,000mph, just 950mph, and they don’t think it’s good enough. Again, if this is the case, and the trainers are the ones holding Melo out – and not Melo himself – I would not expect Melo back before the ASB.
Whose decision is it in the end, though? A trainer’s, or a player’s? If it’s (and I suspect it is) a PLAYER’S decision, in the end, MELO is the only one keeping Melo out.
All I know is that the Nuggets, while they have been able to hold their own against the lesser teams of the league, are going to plunge in the standings if Melo misses this critical upcoming 6 game stretch.
Swats.
Coach Dilfer
First, on the sprained ankle, I have seen NFL players miss months due to a “high ankle sprain”. Don’t know if this is what melo has or not, but he’s not the first player to miss time with an ankle sprain.
They won on monday so I gave the benefit of the doubt, but between Monday and last night’s game, the doubt is gone. This team is winning in spite of it’s coach. Karl is the Trent Dilfer of the NBA, and last night the team wasn’t able to overcome his inneptitude. Can someone please explain the continual three guard lineup? Last time I check, neither Afflalo or J.R. is a small forward. When your small forward is out with injury, giving minutes to your third point guard makes as much sense as playing Malik Allen if Billups is out with an injury. Performances like the last two by Karl only reaffirm that his contract should not be renewed. This team is good enough to compete for a championship in spite of his poor coaching (or in J.R.‘s case, the lack of coaching altogether), and it’s too late to replace him this year, but he has done nothing to justify an extension at this point. Fire George Karl (in june after the playoffs)!
You know what this team needs...
Is a solid SF that can score, rebound and occasionally dish. Where can we get one of those?
I don’t think Melo is faking, he’s just being cautious, extra cautious…while the team is doing well, …well except for last night. Chauncey was very cautious with his groin as well…except when he came back a little too early…after that he was very cautious. Personally, I would be shocked if Melo missed the Laker game, in LA, on national TV…but who knows?
I don’t want to start rumors of Melo faking it. I’m not in that locker room. I’m not talking to Nuggets trainer Jim Gillen every day. It’s not my body. But I am questioning Melo’s toughness because a) he didn’t have a severely sprained ankle, and b) it doesn’t take two weeks to recover from a sprained ankle.
I disagree with you on this Andrew. I have suffered several severely sprained ankles, and it took me months of rehab and running on it before I felt comfortable, and this was when I was in my 20’s. I jacked my ankle back in July and reinjured it twice since. Even with strengthening and conditioning that he gets, you don’t recover from this overnight.
My perspective on the game.
Melo didn’t play, the Nuggets could have used his scoring. That’s obvious, but there’s nothing we could have done about it. As for the players on the court, I saw some good things and some bad things last night. The bad things are usually more prevalent in a loss, so I’ll start there.
The guys are tired. Shots were clanking off the front of the rim all night long and the extra effort on the boards just wasn’t there. No one seemed willing to step up and take the scoring load. We passed the ball so many times, often with open lanes in front, that it seemed as though guys just had to throw a ball up to beat the shot clock.
Chauncey – No free throws? It was obvious that he wasn’t as aggressive last night as usual, he only drove a few times to the rim (and didn’t get the calls he should have) but seemed like he was too willing to settle for the pull-up three.
JR – It seems that everyone picking on JR shooting the ball too much finally got him to stop chucking it, to the demise of the team. On a night when we needed JR, or anyone, to score a handful, he didn’t seem to want the ball. (Damned if you do, damned if you don’t JR. Just keep ballin’)
Nene – Come on big guy. Honestly, what opponent is big enough that you can’t back him down, or quick enough that you can’t spin right by him? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Bueller? I didn’t think so. Buck up little camper, there’s no reason you shouldn’t be bulldozing into the lane. Out with 6 offensive fouls? Better than 6 ticky-tack fouls. At least you should get to earn them.
Birdman – Dood. Blocks are sweet and all, and it’s kinda your calling card – but we strong defense and stronger rebounding. When those guys head fake, you’ve got ‘em dead-to-rights, not the other way around. Don’t let ‘em pull you in.
Afflalo – Love the hustle. Love the hustle. Love the hustle. But make your free throws.
Lawson – These other teams don’t respect you. You know what that means. Seriously, drive the lane, force the contact, make the bucket. After the third time they’re so preoccupied with you that any pass you make will be an assist. That’s just the way it is. It’s the Law son.
Cont.
Graham – Stay aggressive. We need a guy who drives to the rim, not a guy who shoots jumpers.
AC – Second game in a row you played good minutes. I’ll get hell for this but at least the +/- is in your favor.
KMart – You’ve still got my vote for President. But I wish you would drive the lane when it’s open rather than settling for the 17 footer. But really, that’s my only criticism.
Karl – George, George, George, George, George. You’ve been a coach for a long time. I doubt there is much I could say that would change your mind but I have to try. It seems to me like you let a rotation that isn’t working stay in the game for extended minutes, and then pull the quick plug on the rotations that get you back in the game. I’m sure some of it is just trying to limit minutes, but sometimes it seems as though you don’t want to win. Momentum is huge, but it’s more applicable to the guys on the court than the guys on the bench.
rotation
no doubt on the rotation last night. Graham started off hot, scoring 10 in the first quarter. Karl rests him, which makes sense, for a three guard lineup which doesn’t, then keeps A.C. in the game forever and doesn’t put Graham back in until the very end of the second quarter.
Fire George Karl (in June after the Playoffs)!
I thought AC played okay
for AC, but how could Karl EVER think that a three-guard lineup with AC and Lawson and Afflalo/JR would be productive? That limits our offensive potential to no end, and creates mismatches on the defensive end because of height alone.
Yeah, I saw that too.
I don’t think we’re screwed. I think that we’re better off BECAUSE we lost that Suns game. I’m not saying we’ll win, but I think our chances are better.
Chauncey has had two bad games in a row, but only played 35ish minutes. KMart had a bad shooting night, but has shown that he’s tough as nails and not giving up. Nene came out of his shell a little more last night, maybe we’ll get lucky and he’ll show us something tomorrow night. Graham looked a little more comfortable last night. Lawson is going to absolutely go off, the Lakers have always had trouble with small, quick guards.
Plus, this is THE game for the Nuggets in this stretch. Everyone is saying that the Lakers are the number 1 team with Denver a distant 2. If they can’t get up for this game, when will they?
Also, the last three games Anthony has been a game-time scratch. For all the conspiracy theorists here, maybe they’re saying Melo won’t play so that when he does, it’s a boost to the team’s morale AND we can pretend like the Lakers won’t have planned for him.
I'm still worried though
The way the defense has looked lately, I’m worried that the Lakers are going to walk all over them. They obviously have no problem with it either. Not to mention how tired the Nuggets look. Yeah, Kobe is all banged up, but they have so many weapons on their team, it’s scary.
Win or lose, I hope Denver show some heart out there, because if they don’t, they’ll never get the proper respect they so deserve. Well, they probably won’t anyway, but it doesn’t hurt to try.
This pretty much throws andrews theory on Melo
into the rubbish bin. No way Melo doesn’t play on national TV, against the Lakers and his good friend Kobe Bryant unless his is simply physically unable to do it
he must be faking it
thats the only possible explanation, couldn’t possibly be because he’s too hurt to play
It was brutal....
…watching the three-guard lineup and having to watch AC and Lawson get abused by Jason Richardson on the block.
Why are the Nuggets so insistant on switching on that high pick and roll too? Nash had Nene on skates on multiple occassions, Frye rained 3s over our small guards, and on the roll, Amar’e just dominated with easy buckets in the paint over smaller guys.
That’s an adjustment that MUST be made on the fly in the game. Karl 2nd and 3rd quarter = EPIC FAIL!
by 12-piece Nuggets on Feb 4, 2010 11:06 AM MST up reply actions
Oh my god
That lineup was like watching five guys go, “uh, I don’t know. Ummmm, you shoot it!”
awful. That’s when the game got given away. Karl gave the suns the game. Period.
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 4, 2010 11:30 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
Eh, what could he have done
Graham cooled off after the first. Chauncey and JR weren’t really hitting. As far as the rotation goes he didn’t really have much options in his backcourt and at the 3. amazingly, even though I have never advocated him, this would have been a time wher Balkman should have saw soem minutes. Nuggets could have used him on defense. On offense I felt like the Nuggets need to pound the ball inside more. Kmart and Nene were unstoppable down there in the first half and then the Nuggets went completely away from it and settled for jumpers at the end of the shot clock.
this is true
I think that Amare swat really took the wind out of Nene. On the bright side, did you see those break away dunks he had? Dude was taking off almost from the free throw line, who knew Nene could jump like that? Which begs the question if Nene knows he can jump like that then why the $%%^%$ doesn’t he dunk all the time?!!!
Lawson should have played more
I wish GK would show a little more confidence in him especially when Chauncey is struggling as bad as he was last night. 20 minutes and probably only 15 or so of non-garbage time. That’s not enough for a player as good as TY
by runningdonut on Feb 4, 2010 11:03 AM MST up reply actions
Ugh
No comment on the Melo “fake” injury. The only guy in powder blue giving it his all was Rocky. No hustle, no sense of urgency, no team play, no driving to the rim, nothing but 48 wasted basketball minutes. karl should have rested the starters for the whole damn game if that’s how they were gonna play.
AA’s hustle on the D, albeit brief, was nice to see. Too bad he wasn’t conecting any shots.
Nene played like the Boogie Man was waiting in the paint for him.
Ty kept passing up shots, WTF LAWson?
CB1 and K-Mart look tired as all hell.
It would have been nice if the Refs would have called a second violation on the Suns every now and again. I swear they camped out in the paint, and made it difficult for the Nuggs to get any inside game going. Then again the Nuggs didn’t look all that interested in driving to the rim.
+1
" I swear they camped out in the paint"
by Artimus Mangilord on Feb 4, 2010 12:56 PM MST up reply actions
FYI
The red hot Nugs could turn into the ice cold Nugs very quickly with the next five games (especially the next two) if Melo doesn’t come back. Be mentally prepared.
Everybody looked tired
They had no energy, especially Billups. Like I said before, Martin and Billups can only do so much. I was hoping J.R. and Affalo could step it up, but it didn’t happen.
I’m no longer calling Andersen “Birdman”. Every time I see him with the ball, I always cringe and hope he doesn’t do anything stupid. He’s been turning the ball over more then usual too, so that should raise another flag. Somebody needs to work with him and the damned pump fakes. Crap is getting old.
Overall though, they lost because the word “Defense” wasn’t in their minds. Very upsetting.
This is opinion and not analysis
There isn’t much basis behind Andrew’s stance rather than his own observations. Personally as a fan I wouldn’t question a players toughness or manhood unless I didn’t have any respect for them. It’s a conspiracy theory and shouldn’t really be the focus of the game recap which is unfortunate. It reminds me of the Rick Riley stuff that went up here earlier and should be separate from the Nuggets basketball game talk.
by runningdonut on Feb 4, 2010 10:46 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
This is how I feel as well
Obviously we are all frustrated with Melo’s continued absence, but is that really a reason to stir up unnecessary conspiracy theories? I could understand if this were one of those “trade JR trade Nene trade Melo fire GK” kneejerk Fanposts that DS seems to have a lot of following bad games, but for Andrew to write something like this is a little strange.
by Uh on Feb 4, 2010 8:53 PM MST up reply actions
Whew
Last night was rough for us Nuggets fans.
- No Melo again, get blown out at home by a Western Conference playoff team that usually stinks on the road
- Kobe hobbles on a bad ankle all night and scores only 5, but the Fakers manage to eke out a 2-point win over the Bobcats
- The Jazz win their 7th straight game
- The Mavs overcome Monta Ellis scoring 46 on 17-23 shooting
Did anything go right for the Nugs last night? Ridiculous how fast things can turn around. Seemed like we were on top of the world on Sunday after spanking the Hated Spurs on ABC.
Yeah....
I’m gonna get blasted for this but Kobe does the opposite. I think he likes to blow things out of purportion so he can “play through it” and be the hero.
It’s not a good comparison.
by SternfluffsKobe on Feb 4, 2010 11:34 AM MST via mobile up reply actions
I agree
I wasn’t trying to compare Kobe’s injury to Melo’s or anything.
I totally agree that Kobe blows stuff out of proportion.
But then, he may be my least favorite professional athlete in the world, so I’m always ready to believe the worst about him.
by ParkHillNative on Feb 4, 2010 12:26 PM MST up reply actions
Pierce did it!
i still hate his guts for it too.
by Joelsopinion on Feb 4, 2010 12:33 PM MST up reply actions
Oh and re. Melo
I don’t know what to think, frankly. I can see all sides of this one. I guess I lean a little towards believing that the injury is worse than he wants to admit.
At this point I would almost say that I wish he’d just skip everything until the All-Star break, and then also skip the All-Star game itself, and come back hopefully totally healed for that Cavs-Wiz b2b.
But , I think that upcoming game against the Mavs should pretty much be considered a playoff game. There are only 3 games against the Mavs on the schedule for the whole season, so there’s not going to be any 2-2 split this year. The Nugs desperately need to beat the Mavs in both remaining games.
If he doesn’t come back until the Dallas game, or later, and still decides to play in the All-Star game I am going to be pissed off. These games are all crucial for seeding, and Billups is playing through not being 100%. Since when have you ever heard a legit superstar tell the media that he won’t come back and play until he is 100%? The coaches didn’t even say that, Melo did. Do you think that Kobe Bryant is at 100%? With his sore ankle and broken finger? Melo, I love you man, but come on! We aren’t expecting 40 a night, but at least putting out the effort for you teammates should not have to be asked for! Let’s go! And if it’s really that bad, you better freaking take the days off and not play in the All-Star game, or something really is wrong with this whole situation.
Andersen
Has been playing inured too and it’s REALLY starting to show. Guy can’t even take a day off.
I’d be pissed off too if Melo doesn’t play in the next few days and plays in the All-Star. He and Chauncey shouldn’t play. Chauncey is TIRED!!!
If he makes a miracle recovery just in time for the allstar game
I’ll call shenanigans!
Let’s hope it’s a case of the player knows his body better than the coach.
by Joelsopinion on Feb 4, 2010 12:43 PM MST up reply actions
All-Star Game.
There is a big difference here between an All-Star game and a regular season game. Melo already said that he can run and has been practicing. What he can’t do is be explosive and make the hard turns on that ankle. Seriously, who gives 100% in the All-Star game? He’ll play his 10 minutes, shoot a couple of jumpers, play lazy defense (like everyone else) and be just fine. WAY different from being the focal point on your team, working through double-teams, and actually being expected to defend and rebound.
That's my point exactly.
Bird has been injured since the start of the year and just keeps playing through it. Unfortunately, I don’t think that has helped either himself or the team. If taking 2 weeks off would have helped him play better down the stretch I would have been all for it.
So the question comes down to, are the Nuggets better with a hobbled Melo who can’t play 100% or without Melo entirely. Even including last night’s game the Nuggets are 8-4 when Melo is out of the lineup. That tells me that there isn’t a big hurry. Of course we want him back as soon as possible, but not if his ankle isn’t ready.
Good points
On the other hand, have the Nugs maybe gone as far as they can go without Melo? Chauncey’s been great but it seems like maybe he’s starting to get worn out. K-Mart was just out of his mind against the Spurs, but he can’t be counted on to play like that on a regular basis.
I’m afraid that 8-4 might start getting worse and worse as time goes along.
by ParkHillNative on Feb 4, 2010 12:54 PM MST up reply actions
And I totally agree.
All I’m saying is that last night’s decision was most likely made based on the Nuggets’ past success.
And I would urge any future decisions to be made based on what’s best for the team’s chances of getting that golden ball.
Totally agree
They’ve been .500 in the last 4 games without Melo. That’s a sign of fatigue. Melo needs to play. Whether or not he can is another issue.
Resting injured players
Is a good thing. Chauncey didn’t rush back and look at the results. Prior to the Spurs game, he’s been terrific. Sure, we’d like Melo to come back, but I don’t want to see him struggle like Andersen. As much as I’d hate it, if it means we have to wait till Tuesday for Melo, then so be it.
Okay, lot to address in this recap and from the last few days:
1) Andrew and all are certainly entitled to their opinion. I trust Melo 100% and bevlieve he absolutely will and want’s to play when he feels he won’t risk further injury to the ankle (he’s played through bone spurs in his elbow, tweaks, twists, you name it . . . the guy is tough and gets mauled every game). Of course, if he doesn’t play before the All-Star game and then plays in that, I’ll be extremely pissed-off.
2) My big issue is the way the organization has handled it: Melo saying he thinks he’ll be able to play every game is fine, he’s showing he wants to play. The team, however, (meaning Karl) should not commit to anything. The team should not be throwing out any hints that he can play . . . should just say it’s day to day and a game time decision, not “I think he’ll be able to play”. That just fans the fire and feed speculation like this.
3) Ankles are NOTHING to mess with, particularly high ankle sprains,which this one looked like when it happened. I saw this happen and my immediate reaction was “shit that looked bad”. I didn’t understand Melo/others saying it didn’t look bad. As many others have said, ankle sprains can impact you for a long time if you don’t let them heal . . . players careers have been seriously derailed for months and even years. Give him time.
4) The timing of his injury sucks, as the schedule is getting brutal. I thought Melo was holding out until we hit the brutal stretch (starting at LA tomorrow night), but with this later news of missing the next two games, that indicates he’s not healthy yet . . . not that he is being weak or just needs to tough it out. Of any game this year, Melo wants to play tomorrow night. He knows what kind of pub he/the Nugs would get from a win in LA. Particularly with his relationship with Kobe and after last year’s playoff series. Dude is hurt. This is like when they were playing the Cavs on national TV and he sat out with the knee. He sat out because he didn’t want to hurt the team. That’s what’s heppening now.
5) It’s crazy how the Nugs lose one game and all of a sudden, it’s painfully apparent how important Melo is to this team. All of these arguments about how the team “isn’t much worse” without Melo or how he doesn’t mean as much to the team as other stars mean to their teams are disappearing. All of a sudden the Nuggets are only 7-4 without him (lower winning % than the season as a whole), the other players are looking completely worn out from taking on bigger roles since he’s been out, and we’re entering a stretch of games that we’ll gladly take an even split without Melo. Seems like he’s pretty important to me.
My two cents.
by blooming rock on Feb 4, 2010 1:42 PM MST reply actions 1 recs
Agreed with #2
They get you all hyped up and then, at the lest second, “Hey by the way, Melo will not play in tonight’s game”. Total bullshit!
Damn, there’s a lot of freaking out going on in here…
What is JR’s pregame thing that he does with the fans during intro’s? I haven’t seen it before.
One thing he does along with Balkman...
They go shake hands and high-five most of the folks sitting courtside (opposite of the benches). It’s pretty sweet.
I’ve also noticed Rodney Billups sitting courtside (at the Bobcats game) and Chauncey and Malik “Tacos” Allen seemed to have some running conversations with him … pretty fun.
Denver Stiffs.com: Defending the sovereignty of Nuggets Nation.
Seems like a whole bunch of overreaction
bad game against a good team on fire(shooting wise last night). No Melo is finally having an effect on the players but Melo needs to be 100%. I am aware a 3 game losing streak by Super Bowl Sunday is very likely w/o Melo. But even that would at worst tie us for 2nd in the West and we are still better than the other teams competing for that slot. With a fresh Melo coming back the 2 seed should be ours. Hopefully Kobe plays on his busted ankle and fucks himself up resulting in A) the Lakers being far easier to beat in the WCF and B) proving Melo made the smart decision…oh and C) making ESPN cry for 48 hours straight.
March 14, 2010: The great one returns!
Andrew's rant shouldn't surprise anyone
He’s always had an issue with Melo. It’s almost as if he’s glad SOMEONE made the Nuggets worth watching, but in the back of his mind he wishes it had been someone else. It’s like he had a life saving organ transplant, only to find out the donor was a convicted pedophile.
When Iverson was here, Melo was tradable. Now that Chauncey’s here, Melo’s the best player on the Nuggets, but certainly not the MVP of the team. Andrew is usually more discreet, but I guess this recent injury issue has finally caused him to show his hand.
Anyone who has ever dealt with an ankle injury knew that Melo would be out for at least 2 weeks with the way he landed. I was laughing to myself when he said he would be ready to go the following Monday. I’m sure the ankle was still warm from playing in the game when he said and he obviously had not seen the film for himself.
If anyone remembers , Melo tried to stay in the game and play through the injury. A timeout was called while Melo yelled “NO TIMEOUT!!” from down the court. Thankfully, someone saw ho bad it was and was smart enough to take him out immediately.
My guess is that Melo will be back against San Antonio at the earliest. Hopefully that will provide enough time to realize that “FireGeorgeKarl/DenverStiffs” would have never been created without Melo being in Denver. I could speculate that Andrew wrote this piece when he was drunk, but I don’t want to start any rumors about Andrew having a drinking problem.
Andrew, seriously, you usually do a good job and it’s good to see what your passion has grown into. So please don’t let a few heart-on-your-sleeve moments be the downfall of something you’ve taken time to build. You’re better than writing pieces like this, simply for shock value. Melo isn’t perfect by any means and he’s given all of us reasons to criticize his game. But, I really don’t know what you’ve seen over the past 6 years to make you question his heart.
by TraSoul82 on Feb 5, 2010 3:01 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
First post here
I’ve been reading for awhile and decided to join. I don’t think Melo is faking it, probably just playing it safe. I’d rather drop a few games in mid season and finish strong with a healthy Melo then win a few more games now but lose down the road because Melo still isn’t right
Wait a second. I'm getting an idea. No, false alarm. No. Yes! No. Yep. Nope, waaiiit, no. Yes. Yes. No. YES!!!!
I wrote a reply above to a piece by Andrew Feinstein
But upon further review, I would swear it was written by Mark Kizla.
2009 Colorado Rockies - Historic turnaround to win NL WildCard
Brad Hawpe - Will prove the doubters wrong
Troy Tulowitzki - Best SS in the MLB - 2010 MVP
"With a guy like Melo, it’s tough to stop him with one person. You can’t. I don’t know one guy who can stop Melo on a consistent basis."-CP3
PS Let's win the NL West in 2010, shall we?
Ouch...
Ok…now THAT one hurt…
-A
Andrew Feinstein | DenverStiffs.com | denverstiffs@gmail.com
by Andrew Feinstein on Feb 5, 2010 8:42 AM MST up reply actions
Sorry Andrew, I was kidding mostly.
I enjoy this site quite a bit. My main reason for this comment, is it reminded me of some of the hit pieces that Kizla has written. I hope you will take this as a constructive criticism. I was rather shocked at your piece that really seemed to call out Melo unfairly. Just stay above Kizla’s level please :)
2009 Colorado Rockies - Historic turnaround to win NL WildCard
Brad Hawpe - Will prove the doubters wrong
Troy Tulowitzki - Best SS in the MLB - 2010 MVP
"With a guy like Melo, it’s tough to stop him with one person. You can’t. I don’t know one guy who can stop Melo on a consistent basis."-CP3
PS Let's win the NL West in 2010, shall we?
No worries!
Hey SDcat -
I knew you were joking and I probably deserve a lot of the heat I’m taking on this one because I didn’t word my argument properly. But for readers of this site to think I’m anti-Melo is patently false. I’ve written countless columns praising Melo and have gone out of my way to routinely acknowledge (as I did in this column) we’d be nowhere without him.
That said, readers need to keep in mind that I don’t just go to the games but I’m very fortunate to sit close enough to see things you don’t catch on TV, and it’s my job to point them out as a fan. For example, I took a lot of heat (again) for calling out Melo for wincing in pain and slowly getting back on defense, and then remarkably feeling great on offense. This happens so often and has since Melo’s rookie year, that’s it’s comical. The other media guys won’t go on record like I will on this, but everyone knows it. Simply put, Melo is a bit of a diva (hey, so is D-Wade)…that doesn’t mean he’s a bad guy, a bad basketball player or a faker…it just means he’s not the toughest player on the team.
I’ll leave you with one final thought: does anyone honestly think that if these were playoff games Melo would be sitting out? Or if Kobe Bryant had a similar injury he’d be missing this many games? We all know the answer: no chance.
Anyway, if you come to tonight’s event at Choppers I’ll buy you a beer as long as you promise not to compare me to Kiszla again!
Andrew Feinstein | DenverStiffs.com | denverstiffs@gmail.com
by Andrew Feinstein on Feb 5, 2010 1:31 PM MST up reply actions
"...readers need to keep in mind that I don't just go to the games but I am very fortunate to sit close enough to see things you don't catch on TV..."
And if you were Governor of Alaska, you’d probably be an expert on foreign affairs because you could see Russia from your house. Right?
I’ve never wanted to bring it up because it might seem like sour grapes BUT, maybe you should watch more of the games on TV (or at least DVR and watch before writing the recaps?) The coverage is pretty insightful and – ultimately – Hastings and Marlowe are better “insiders” than anyone in the media because they travel with and are friendly with the players and coaches. I actually bet that you would have chosen your words VERY differently (or avoided the topic all together) if you had seen Melo’s mid-game interview or listened to Hastings talk about how “tricky” injuries like Melo’s tend to be.
Practice doesn't make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect.
In Melo’s defense on the “hurt on defense, well enough to score on offense” situation, I think most athletes/former athletes can sympathize with him on this issue. I played soccer (waits knowingly for the “grass fairy” jokes) at a high level throughout my life. I had ankle problems as well. Any time my ankle was hurt during a game, but not bad enough to go down and stay down, you are kind of standing there waiting for the ball to go out so you can be subbed or recover. You don’t play defense because you don’t know how bad it is yet or if you can still play on it, but if the ball rolls to you out of a tackle or is passed to you unknowingly, your instinct kicks in and you start playing again because you feel a responsibility to perform for your team and not give the ball away or be a liability. I don’t think he does it on purpose, I think it’s instinct.
Ha, thanks for the offer on the beer.
as long as you don’t write like Kizla, I won’t compare you to him :)
Unfortunately, I’m watching from a my mom’s hospital room :(. I would love to hang out with you Stiffs!
Go NUGGETS!!
Troy Tulowitzki - Best SS in the MLB - 2010 MVP
"With a guy like Melo, it’s tough to stop him with one person. You can’t. I don’t know one guy who can stop Melo on a consistent basis."-CP3
Brad Hawpe - Will prove the doubters wrong
PS Let's win the NL West in 2010, shall we?
Wednesday night sucked
The game Wednesday was a let down. All of the sudden the Nuggets are just another team. And, I’m not going to lie: I don’t get excited enough about average teams to post on sports blogs and whatnot. I’m a Nuggets fan and always will be, but man. The game had me thinking I was some sort of fool for believing in this team in the first place.
But I’m not a fool. And the Nuggets are still contenders. They had a bad game against a decent team. Which is better than the last time I was disgusted with this team, having a bad game against an awful team.
I want to make this point: Melo can have awful shooting nights just like anyone else. Sometimes Denver can do good without him in the line-up. But when the team is flat and cold, there is something to be said about the fact that Melo will find his way to get points.
Denver did pretty good without him. But for this team to challenge LA, they need a healthy Melo. I think this should be obvious to all.
Peace,
FA
Member: 10-man rotation for deep playoff push advocacy group

by 












