Denver Stiffs: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Cowboy Altitude for Wyoming Fans!

Why replacement refs might be a good thing...

Melo_ref_mediumCount me out on the list of people who are worried about NBA referees being locked out.  In fact, I think it will be a good thing...especially for the Nuggets.

Star-divide

First off, I encourage readers of this blog to read ESPN's Bill Simmons excellent treatise on the sad state of NBA officiating.  Simmons rightly points out that too many refs are too short and too old to accurately call one of the fastest and most physical sports, often played above a 10-foot rim no less.  And to quote my Cousin Paul (who unfortunately is a die-hard Lakers fan), the fundamental problem with NBA officiating is that "they referee the player, not the play."  I've never heard a more true statement.

So why exactly will replacement refs be a bad thing?  Traveling will be called consistently?  Flopping will be legislated properly (as a no-call for once as it rightly should be)?  The Lakers won't receive an exorbitant number of favorable calls and no-calls?  Oh, what a shame that'd be.

From a Nuggets fan's perspective, the current officiating apparatus couldn't get any worse as the Nuggets are one of the most whistled, least respected teams by NBA refs.  To be fair, some of this is justified as the Nuggets have been notorious whiners in the Carmelo Anthony/Allen Iverson Era.  Melo, Marcus Camby, Kenyon Martin, Allen Iverson, Dahntay Jones, Nene and the all-time Nuggets whiner, J.R. Smith, have never received a call that they've agreed with.  Even the dignified Chauncey Billups jaws incessantly with the zebras throughout every game, enough to draw 10 technical fouls last season.  In fact, for the 2008-09 season the Nuggets ranked fifth overall in personal fouls called (note that I said "called," not "committed") and three Nuggets ranked in the top 20 for technical fouls called with Melo finishing third overall in the NBA.  And, of course, it doesn't help that Nuggets head coach George Karl all but refuses to work the refs throughout games, rarely drawing a crucial call or no-call that goes the Nuggets way down the stretch.

The bottom line is that neither disputed calls nor disputed no-calls should be determining the outcomes of any NBA games, whether the Nuggets are participating in said games or not.  But until the NBA outlaws players from talking to the refs (something I'm in favor of, by the way), it will always be a whiners league.  Just like the refs shouldn't capitulate with a free call or a crucial no-call when a "star" like Kobe Bryant whines in their ear all night, they also shouldn't be hammering the Nuggets with horrendous calls for being malcontents on the court.  

While current NBA referees undoubtedly have a passion for what they do and have worked tirelessly to reach their sport's greatest stage, passion and work ethic don't necessarily translate into competence.  I also recognize that it's not fair to paint all NBA referees with the same tattered brush.  But it's utterly ridiculous that I can name 20 referees if asked.  I shouldn't know any of their names, because their name should never come up.  

If the "real" refs get locked out for a few months while replacement refs get a shot at calling a better game, so be it.  I'd like the NBA to take this a step further and ban all players from talking to the refs during the preseason.  Why should these replacement refs be influenced by the players they officiate any more than their locked out predecessors already are?

 "Replacement" refs?  I say, bring 'em on!  In a season in which the NBA slammed the Nuggets with a Western Conference high 22 back-to-back games, we'll take any advantage we can get.

0 recs  |  Comment 22 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

The replacement refs are gonna be worse than the regular ones

Just to throw that out there. Remember that the last time the league locked out the refs, the number of fines and suspensions per game almost quadrupled from the season before it. I don’t waI

"I always believe there's a reason why you go through everything." -John Elway

by LACK on Sep 21, 2009 4:10 PM MDT reply actions  

Sure, the refs suck and hate us

But they are going to hate us more now. For all we know, David Stern might make James Worthy, the corpse of Bruno Sundov, and Kobe’s wife the ref squad for a Nuggets-Lakers game. Why? Because that’s just how the NBA rolls

"I always believe there's a reason why you go through everything." -John Elway

by LACK on Sep 21, 2009 4:12 PM MDT reply actions  

here’s the thing: these refs will probably be more star-centric, as they’ll be overcome by the Kobe, Wade, LeBron type players..

Have you watched D-league, international, or college ball lately? the reffing is absolutely horrible. It makes the NBA reffing look fantastic. the last time they tried this it was an unmitigated disaster.

"If the Lakers are Hollywood, then we are South Central." - Clipper fan.

by Cablinasian on Sep 21, 2009 5:06 PM MDT reply actions  

Assumption

LACK is 100 percent correct, there is a reason the replacement refs don’t work in the NBA or have been fired. They are worse, try watching a WNBA/D-league/NCAA game. Of course there’s always a few bad apples., but the cream tends to rise to the top just like any other profession out there. Also, being younger or taller doesnt automatically make a better ref, it’s about being experienced, thick-skinned and decisive.

I’m not sure how replacement refs are going to equal an advantage for Denver. Look at the playoffs last year, there were 2 plays the JR Smith jump ball and Carmelo intentional foul no-call that both swung Nuggets victories. The Nugs were generally rewarded for their aggressive style of play and the officiating throughout the playoffs I thought was good. Whining about the refs is about the lowest form of sports fandom I can imagine. It’s for perennial losers and fanboys who can’t criticize or see the game outside of their team-centric bias. There’s absolutely no fact or legitimate thinking behind the idea that this is going to turn out in the Nuggets favor.

by runningdonut on Sep 21, 2009 5:16 PM MDT reply actions  

Great Call!!!!!!!!!!!

I love the idea and I hope it comes to fruition. I am one to beleive that Donaghy was not the only one “connected” and throwing games for money. Look at the referees in the NBA (Bill Simmons did a pretty good write up on this one too). Half of them look like they belong to the mafia. The Nuggets are one of those small market teams that the NBA does not want to win. They want the ratings of the Lakers, Celtics, Cavaliers, Mavericks, Rockets, Spurs, Sixers, etc to further the growth of the game in places like China and India. I wouldn’t be the least bit suprised if the NBA is working the refs to make those big market teams into the best teams in the NBA. Refereeing isn’t any where close to as bad in any sport as it is in NBA basketball. Maybe the new puny referees won’t have the “connections” that the current crop does and we can watch a “fair” season of basketball for once.

by Gasus on Sep 21, 2009 5:19 PM MDT reply actions  

Against the Pacers no less!

How many people living in Taiwan know that the Pacers exist?

"I always believe there's a reason why you go through everything." -John Elway

by LACK on Sep 22, 2009 9:50 PM MDT up reply actions  

THE PUNCH

there is a book by john feinstein written about a fight that happened back in the 1970’s that changed the nba and the lives of 2 players involved. there is a need to keep things under control without determining the outcome of the game by the refs. the gambling ref scandal did not help the locked out officials. the best way to keep the players from talking to the refs is have a technical foul count toward the personal foul total. there was an attempt to have former nba players become refs. only a few took part. college refs work full time jobs outside of basketball. bobby knight had a problem with them working too many games. no easy answers on this one. last thing i want to see is a constant parade from one free throw line to the other. remember the old saying- i went to a boxing match the other night and a hockey game broke out.

by nohoops4u on Sep 21, 2009 5:35 PM MDT reply actions  

I’ve always wanted to read that book. Instead I just picked up Tip Off, the story about the 1984 Draft and how it changed the NBA. So far not a bad read.

Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.

by FrankD on Sep 21, 2009 9:22 PM MDT up reply actions  

another good book

A SEASON ON THE RESERVATION by kareem abdul-jabbar. just when you thought you knew everything about kareem. go to amazon and you can read some of the first chapter of THE PUNCH. both are true stories.

by nohoops4u on Sep 22, 2009 2:21 AM MDT up reply actions  

Dollar Tree

I bought The Punch at a Dollar Tree here in Denver a couple of weeks ago. Go check it out, well worth it for $1. They usually have two or three good basketball books at the Dollar Tree every month.

by BrianD on Sep 22, 2009 8:39 AM MDT up reply actions  

Funny, I saw it at the Dollar Tree by me too, and I’m far from Denver.

Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.

by FrankD on Sep 24, 2009 7:37 PM MDT up reply actions  

Hmm...

I am going to miss Violet Palmer.

Bwhahahahahahahahahhahahahah!!!!

by Missing Lynx on Sep 21, 2009 6:16 PM MDT reply actions  

Joey Crawford is worse -- conspicuously so

Joey Crawford, of course, double-T’d Tim Duncan for laughing. On the bench. He’s done similar stuff and disrupted entire playoff series.

Or how about Chauncey Billups being called for the ref’s own foul?

Joey Crawford, ladies and gents!

Every time anyone mentions Crawford they say something about how he’s one of the best. They’re not doing that because he’s good. They’re doing it because he’s such a vindictive, self-important jerk that he’ll exact revenge at some horrible time. Incompetence is one thing, but this guy is absolutely out of control, and he needs to go.

by feral on Sep 22, 2009 10:06 AM MDT up reply actions  

Does anyone know if WNBA refs are under the same regulations as NBA refs in terms of the lock out?

Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.

by FrankD on Sep 21, 2009 9:24 PM MDT reply actions  

Good Read
And, of course, it doesn’t help that Nuggets head coach George Karl all but refuses to work the refs throughout games, rarely drawing a crucial call or no-call that goes the Nuggets way down the stretch.


Of course the above is 1000% correct. Our guys argue with the refs because their coach won’t stand up for them, end of story.

by GoldenNugget on Sep 21, 2009 11:43 PM MDT reply actions  

Damnit

The first part was just a quote from Andy, the second is my commentary.

by GoldenNugget on Sep 21, 2009 11:43 PM MDT up reply actions  

haha the blockquote thing can be a bit tricky at first

Follow the Penguins on SBN @ Pensburgh.com and twitter.

by FrankD on Sep 22, 2009 8:27 AM MDT up reply actions  

And

I love the new Stiff List, good stuff there.

by GoldenNugget on Sep 21, 2009 11:44 PM MDT up reply actions  

I think

I think the NBA refs even still hold a grudge against the Nuggets from the old Dan Issel days. Remeber how much he got under the skin of Joey Crawford and Steve Jaffey? Those two guys have never lightened up on the Nuggets, even well after Issel’s departure.

by All Day Jay on Sep 22, 2009 1:19 AM MDT reply actions  

On a plane

I was on a plane once with Dan Issel AND Steve Javie. I couldn’t resist the opportunity to talk to them, because I knew they didn’t get along at all. They joked about it a little bit, but I don’t think they were going to meet each other on a golf course anytime soon. Check out Issel’s Parting Shots book for some great quotes on Joe Crawford. He really hated Crawford when he was a player.

by BrianD on Sep 22, 2009 8:43 AM MDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

The Proprietors
Andrew Feinstein
(denverstiffs@gmail.com)
Nate Timmons
(ntimmons73@yahoo.com)
Start posting about the Nuggets »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

The STIFF LIST (as of 8/30 by Andrew)

STIFF #1: J.R. SMITH 
Remember when I wrote that J.R.'s "nine lives may be up"? Well, that was last January. With Denver police looking closely at J.R. allegedly attacking former 14er Damien Lolar at a recent Pepsi Center shoot-around, it's clear that J.R. will never mature and it's time to move him.

STIFF #2: LEON ROSE AND WORLDWIDE WES
After commandeering LeBron's departure from Cleveland, Rose and Wes are allegedly working to move Melo out of Denver. Let's hope the Nuggets do what's best for Denver and not these two franchise-destroyers.

STIFF #3: RIC BUCHER
The man who once guaranteed that Kobe Bryant had played his last game in a Lakers uniform has been gravy-training on other reporters' Melo-related stories all summer long. Who does Bucher think he is, a sports blogger?

STIFF #4: MARCUS JORDAN
Like father, like son. Last week, His Airness's 19-year-old son tweeted about dropping $50k at the Aria casino in Las Vegas prompting an investigation.

STIFF #5: INDIANA PACERS
Brandon Rush has been suspended five games for violating the NBA's drug policy and 2010 draftee Lance Stephenson was recently arrested on assault charges. Larry Bird sure is doing a great job re-shaping the Pacers' already shoddy image.

DENVER STIFFS ON FACEBOOK

Enter your email for updates

Email:

Denver Stiffs on Twitter

Blogroll

SB Nation Colorado Team Blogs

Purple Row (Rockies)
Mile High Report (Broncos)
Mile High Hockey (Avalanche)
Ralphie Report (CU Buffaloes)

Nuggets-Related Sites

Chris Andersen Files
Denver Nuggets at Basketball-Reference
Denver Nuggets Examiner
Denver Nuggets official website
Denver Nuggets on Wikipedia
Denver Nuggets payroll
Doug Moe quotes
Mile High Fan
Nugg Doctor
Nugg Love
NuggetsHoops.com
Remember the ABA
Roundball Mining Company
Nuggets' Nuggetz
Jason Kosmicki

Denver Sports Media

Benjamin Hochman
Colorado Sports Desk
Dave Krieger
Dino Costa
Drew Litton
Jim Armstrong
Mark Kiszla
Mile High Sports
Woody Paige
The Sports Guys

NBA Team Blogs

Atlanta Hawks
Peachtree Hoops

Boston Celtics
Celtics Blog
Celtics Hub
Red's Army

Charlotte Bobcats
Rufus on Fire

Chicago Bulls
Blog a Bull
By the Horns

Cleveland Cavaliers
Cavs the Blog
Fear the Sword

Dallas Mavericks
Mavs Moneyball
The Two Man Game

Detroit Pistons
Motown String Music

Golden State Warriors
Golden State of Mind

Houston Rockets
The Dream Shake

Indiana Pacers
Indy Cornrows

Los Angeles Clippers
ClipperBlog
Clips Nation

Los Angeles Lakers
Forum Blue and Gold
Silver Screen and Roll

Memphis Grizzlies
3 Shades of Blue
Straight Outta Vancouver

Miami Heat
Peninsula is Mightier

Milwaukee Bucks
Brew Hoop
The Bucky Channel

Minnesota Timberwolves
Canis Hoopus
TWolves Blog

New Jersey Nets
Nets Daily

New Orleans Hornets
At the Hive

New York Knicks
Knickerblogger
Posting and Toasting

Oklahoma City Thunder
Bend it Like Bennett
OKC Thunderballs

Orlando Magic
Third Quarter Collapse

Philadelphia 76ers
Liberty Ballers

Phoenix Suns
Bright Side of the Sun
Valley of the Suns

Portland Trail Blazers
Blaze of Love
Blazersedge
Rip City Forever

Sacramento Kings
Sactown Royalty

San Antonio Spurs
48 Minutes of Hell
Pounding the Rock

Toronto Raptors
Raptors Blog Raptors HQ

Utah Jazz
Frank Layden Admirers
SLC Dunk

Washington Wizards
Bullets Forever

NBA Blogs and Other Recommended Sites

And Here Come the Pretzels
AOL NBA Fanhouse
Ball Don't Lie
Basket Bawful
Basketball Reference
Basketball Statistics
Basketbawful
Bill Simmons
By the Book
Call it Mile High
Deadspin
Free Darko
Girls & Sports Comics
Hardwood Paroxysm
High Level Sport
Hoop Access
Hoops Daily
Hoops Hype
Hoops Vibe
Hoops World
Inside Hoops
Mouthpiece Sports
Need 4 Sheed
OTR Basketball Forum
Outside the Boxscore
Peter Robert Casey
Pro Basketball News
Ridiculous Upside
Slam Online
Sports by Brooks
Stock Lemon
That NBA Lottery Pick
The Basketball Jones
The Big Lead
True Hoop
Wages of Wins Journal
With Leather
With Malice

 

 

 

SBNation.com Recent Stories

NEW YORK CITY NY - AUGUST 12:  Kevin Durant #5 looks on during the World Basketball Festival USAB Showcase at Radio City Music Hall on August 12 2010 in New York City. (Photo by Chris Trotman/Getty Images for Nike) +4 updates

FIBA World Championships 2010: Team USA Routs Iran 88-51, Clinches Top Spot In Group B

FILE - This Feb. 21, 2010, file photo shows Denver Nuggets head coach George Karl before an NBA basketball game against the Boston Celtics,  in Denver. Karl will miss Wednesday night's,  March 10, 2010, game at Minnesota as he undergoes another round of cancer treatment.  (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File) +4 updates

Nuggets Coach George Karl Says He'll Return To Coaching Next Season

Cleveland Cavaliers' Delonte West, right, shoot over Indiana Pacers' Jeff Foster in the first half of a NBA basketball game in Indianapolis, Monday, April 13, 2009.  (AP Photo/Michael Conroy) link

Celtics Sign Free Agent Delonte West

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Nuggets_alternate_logo_small Nate Timmons

Andy-blogger_small Andrew Feinstein